Stealing Athena - Karen Essex

Title: Stealing Athena
Author: Karen Essex
ISBN: 0385519710
Pages: 464
Genre: Historical Fiction
Rating: **** (out of 5)

From the dust jacket:

The Elgin Marbles have been displayed in the British Museum for nearly two hundred years, and for just as long they have been the center of a raging controversy. In Stealing Athena, Karen Essex chronicles the Marbles' amazing journey through the dynamic narratives of Mary Nisbet, wife of the Earl of Elgin, the British ambassador to Constantinople, and Aspasia, the mistress of Perikles, the most powerful man in Athens during that city's Golden Age.

At the height of the Napoleonic Wars, the twenty-one-year-old, newly wed Countess of Elgin, a Scottish heiress and celebrated beauty, enchanted the power brokers of the Ottoman Empire using her charms to obtain their permission for her husband's audacious plan to deconstruct the Parthenon and bring its magnificent sculptures back to England. Two millennia earlier, Aspasia, a female philosopher and courtesan, and a central figure in Athenian life, plied her wits, allure, and influence with equal determination, standing with Perikles at the center of vehement opposition to his vision of building the most exquisite monuments the world had ever seen.

Rich in romance and intrigue, greed and glory, Stealing Athena is an enthralling work of historical fiction and a window into the intimate lives of two of history's most influential and fascinating women.

Though I am a big fan of the historical fiction genre and generally interested in Ancient Greece, for some reason, the description of Stealing Athena didn't capture my interest like it should have. I wanted to read it because I have heard so many positive things about Karen Essex' novel Leonardo's Swans. So, bearing that in mind, I approached my review copy with some trepidation and discovered, to my surprise, that my apprehensions were completely without merit. Stealing Athena is a well researched story that is extremely interesting and beautifully written.

As the description suggests, the novel follows the storylines of two women: Mary and Aspasia. While these two stories are both interesting, they have their respective strong and weak points. There were times I was sorry to leave Aspasia for Mary, and also times when the opposite was true. However, the story seems to be a bit weighted in Mary's direction, as the novel seems to belong to her rather than Aspasia.

Through the novel's progression, these two women find their positions in male-dominated societies unbearable and begin to question the rules that keep their sex subjugated. They are strong-willed and determined to carry out their own wishes. Mary and Aspasia are both well written female characters, which is refreshing, especially in Aspasia's case. There are not many novels of Ancient Greece that are told from a woman's point of view.

Another important character in this novel is that of the Elgin Marbles. According to the British Museum's website:

The 'Elgin Marbles' is a popular term that in its widest use may refer to the collection of stone objects - sculptures, inscriptions and architectural features - acquired by Lord Elgin during his time as ambassador to the Ottoman court of the Sultan in Istanbul. More specifically, and more usually, it is used to refer to those sculptures, inscriptions and architectural features that he acquired in Athens between 1801 and 1805. These objects were purchased by the British Parliament from Lord Elgin in 1816 and presented by Parliament to the British Museum.

The article goes on to detail the size of the Elgin Marbles collection.

This aspect of the novel was one I knew I would dislike greatly. Essex handles the gutting of the Parthenon with as much grace as possible, but it still is painful to read. It did help that Mary had second thoughts about her husband's work many times throughout the novel. The justification that they later offer is that if they hadn't removed the items from the Acropolis, the Turks would have destroyed them. Whether true or not, it is always sad to read about or hear of archaeological treasures being removed from sites for personal gain. However, the Elgin Marbles are a subject that, to my knowledge, have not been approached in historical fiction. They are an important piece of history, and Essex writes them well. She is to be commended on her delicate handling of this difficult subject and her exceptional research into the history of their removal from Greece.

In sum, Stealing Athena is a solid piece of historical fiction. While not absolutely captivating, it is definitely interesting enough to warrant a read. And with that, I leave you with some photographs of the Elgin Marbles from Google Images.


























5 comments:

Ladyslott said...

I agree with a lot of your post. I too found the destruction of the Parthenon very sad, even if it was for a supposed good cause. I enjoyed the photos you posted also. I think my main problem with the book is I really didn't like the characters, I didn't feel attached to any of them and didn't much care about the outcome. unusual for me.

Meghan said...

I also mostly agree with you. I really enjoyed the book because it was well-written and I liked both Mary and Aspasia (although I preferred Mary). It's also really nice to have a dual period historical fiction work out like this that isn't one of the Pink Carnation books (which really count more as romance anyway). On the Elgin Marbles, though, it's hard. I also struggle to condone Lord Elgin's actions and much of the book made me cringe because this possessiveness of ancient artifacts is wrong. I think the marbles should now be restored to Greece, personally, even though I have had the pleasure of seeing them solely because they were in the British Museum. They may have been destroyed in this case, but it smacks of the attitude of western Europe in the 19th century - that everything in the world belonged to them and no culture was superior to their own.

Anyway, I did like the book, despite those reservations! Just a difficult subject. I'll be writing on this at more length when I post its review in a few days (I'm a bit behind on my reviews, I'm reading too much, if that's possible!)

literatehousewife said...

This book sounds really good. I like that you added pictures to your review. I've entered a contest for this book, so I'm really keeping my fingers crossed!

fashion-piranha said...

I can't wait to read this book :) It was so amazing to see the Elgin Marbles last year at the British Museum, but I can only think about how much better it would be to see them back home in Greece.

Carrie K. said...

I'm looking forward to reading this one - my copy is sitting on my to-read pile near the top.

Post a Comment

I welcome comments and read each one I receive. If your comment needs a response, I will provide it in a timely manner, as I read every comment I receive.

Please keep your comments civil and polite! I reserve the right to delete any comments that are rude or inappropriate.

Because of spam, I have to moderate comments on old posts. Please be patient - I will approve your comment quickly.

Welcome!

Welcome! I’m Swapna Krishna, and this is where you’ll find my book reviews. Feel free to look through my review database. I also host the South Asian Review Database and run the South Asian Challenge, which promote the authors and literature of the region.


I do accept books for review, but please take a look at my review policy before pitching me a book. If you have any questions, please contact me.




Follow Me on Pinterest

Subscribe Now

Search Book Reviews

Loading

Currently Reading


Recently Read

2012: Best Books

2011: Best Books

South Asia

Support This Blog

Advertising

Blog Archive

Labels